A Truly Unique Talent

Dr. Eilat Mazar is at it again– running to the press before properly submitting her finds to serious archaeological scrutiny. 

Now it is Solomon’s Wall.  Before it was David’s Palace.  Also the Tsinnor. Also Nehemiah’s Wall.  Also the Seal of Temech.  None of them have stood the test of time– except to those who desperately want to believe…

What’s next?  Bathsheba’s bathtub?  The Queen of Sheba’s guestroom? 

This is not careful, systematic archaeology, yielding a more sophisticated understanding of Iron Age Jerusalem.  It is secular shrine building and idolatrous historical idol worship– consciously or unwittingly serving contemporary religious and political agendas and helping to sabotage any hope of future compromise in Jerusalem. 

Ironic that this news appeared on the same day that the Prime Minister’s new Heritage Plan (see last post) sparked violence. 

Stay tuned for more updates…

Update #1:  In fact here is one factual clarification– the first of many, I expect– this one from Todd Bolen’s BiblePlaces.com blog.

Update #2: In his hyperbolic blog on this discovery, Commentary editor Jonathan Tobin demonstrates how good he is at summarizing hyperbolic archaeological press releases– and how little he actually knows about archaeology.

Update #3Leen Ritmeyer, who can hardly be accused of minimalism, shares his thoughts and experience regarding the discovery of the new  “Solomonic” wall.  Bottom line:  probably late 8th century BCE, a full two centuries after the time of Solomon.

4 thoughts on “A Truly Unique Talent

  1. Pingback: Advice to the State of Israel « Searching for Authenticity

  2. Pingback: Playing With Fire in Jerusalem « Searching for Authenticity

  3. I like Mazar’s phrase: “The city wall that has been uncovered testifies to a ruling presence.” Of course in Jerusalem this `ruling presence’ can only be King Solomon. QED. And the presence of LMLK jars, figurines and bullae – all dating to the late Iron Age – so what?

  4. Pingback: Newsflash from Jerusalem: Pot Calls Kettle Black « Searching for Authenticity

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s